Is McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff A Scam? How to Respond

By Talk About Debt Team
Reviewed by Ben Jackson
Last Updated: February 16, 2026
6 min read
The Bottom Line

McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff is a legitimate collection agency with over 41 years in business. You can respond effectively by requesting debt validation, negotiating settlement, or filing an Answer if sued. Taking action quickly protects your rights and helps you resolve debt while avoiding court judgments.

Answer Your Lawsuit

McCarthy Burgess & Wolff is a legitimate debt collection agency. They’ve operated for over 41 years with A+ BBB accreditation. The company collects debt for credit cards, utilities, medical care, auto loans, and student loans. Their headquarters sits in Bedford Heights, Ohio.

Here’s how to contact McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff:

Respond to McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff Today

MB&W filed a lawsuit against you? Don't risk default judgment and wage garnishment. Draft your Answer in minutes and protect your rights before the deadline expires.

Create Your Answer
  • Phone Number: 888-584-3053
  • Address: 26000 Cannon Rd, Cleveland, OH 44146
  • Website: www.mbandw.com

MB&W receives your account information from original creditors. They’ll call or email you requesting payment. Responding promptly works better than ignoring them. They may help you develop a payment plan if finances are tight.

Below are proven steps to respond to McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff effectively. You can resolve your debt while avoiding court.

Respond to McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff with These Steps

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) contains federal laws governing collection agencies. Understanding these laws improves your chances of a positive outcome. Here are two legal steps you can take when MB&W calls.

Step 1: Ask for More Information

Verify you’re talking to an actual MB&W employee. Scammers sometimes impersonate legitimate collection agencies. Protect yourself by asking questions.

Request full names, employee numbers, and original creditor information. Ask for everything in writing before responding. Legitimate collectors will comply with this request.

Step 2: Request Debt Validation

Debt information sometimes gets mixed up during transfer. You need to verify the debt belongs to you. The amount must be accurate.

Send a debt validation letter to McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff. Request the following information:

  • Breakdown of the debt in question
  • Details of the original creditor
  • Statement allowing you to dispute the debt
  • Statement allowing you to request clarification

Review the debt validation notice carefully. Check for errors or discrepancies. Dispute the debt with Equifax, TransUnion, and Experian if you find mistakes.

Check the date of your last payment. Make sure the statute of limitations hasn’t expired. Making a payment on an old debt restarts the clock. Plan payments if the debt is accurate and belongs to you.

How to Answer a Lawsuit by McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff

McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff rarely files lawsuits immediately. They exhaust other collection avenues first. Court drains their resources too. They’ll contact you multiple times before suing.

Take immediate action if you receive a lawsuit letter. The steps below protect your rights.

File a Written Answer

File a written Answer within 14-30 days of receiving the summons. Our partner Solo helps you draft an Answer quickly. Your response should include all available defenses.

Common defenses include expired statute of limitations and mistaken identity. You can also argue you already paid the debt. Include every defense that applies to your situation.

Plan to Go to Court

Never skip your court date. Failing to appear leads to default judgment. MB&W automatically wins if you don’t show up.

Courts may allow wage garnishment after default judgment. They can access your bank account or place liens on property. Show up even if you can’t pay immediately.

You can represent yourself in court. Prepare thoroughly by following these steps:

  • Research debt collection laws
  • Gather all possible defenses
  • Learn basic court procedures
  • Force MB&W to prove you owe the debt

Make McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff prove the debt amount is accurate. Require proof they own the debt. Check our guide on how to prepare for court for detailed information.

Negotiate with McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff to Settle

You can negotiate the debt and settle outside court. Settling works when the debt is yours and accurate. Consider the following before starting settlement.

  1. Evaluate your finances to determine settlement offers
  2. Contact McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff in writing with an offer
  3. Negotiate back-and-forth until you agree on an amount
  4. Get the agreement in writing with signatures from both parties
  5. Pay the settlement amount and keep detailed payment records

Our partner Solo offers tools to draft settlement letters. You can track correspondence and initiate payment safely. Your financial information stays protected throughout the process.

What to Do If McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff Violates Your Rights

The FDCPA protects you from abusive collection practices. McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff must follow strict rules. Report violations immediately if they occur.

Collectors cannot harass, threaten, or use deceptive tactics. They can’t call before 8 AM or after 9 PM. They must stop contacting you at work if you request it.

Document every violation with dates and details. File a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. You can also report violations to your state attorney general.

Consider suing for FDCPA violations. You may recover damages up to $1,000 plus attorney fees. Courts take debt collector violations seriously.

Protecting Your Credit While Dealing with MB&W

Collection accounts damage your credit score significantly. Act quickly to minimize the impact. Address the debt before it worsens.

Check your credit reports from all three bureaus. Look for inaccuracies in the MB&W collection account. Dispute any errors you find immediately.

Negotiate a “pay for delete” agreement if possible. MB&W removes the collection account after you pay. Get this agreement in writing before making payment.

Start rebuilding your credit after settling. Our partner Kikoff helps you improve your credit score. Building positive payment history offsets collection damage.

Alternative Options for Managing MB&W Debt

Settlement isn’t your only option. Other strategies can help you resolve McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff debt. Explore all possibilities before deciding.

Payment Plans

MB&W often accepts payment plans for outstanding debt. Monthly payments make large debts manageable. Contact them to discuss available options.

Propose a realistic payment amount you can afford. Get the payment plan terms in writing. Make every payment on time to avoid default.

Debt Management Programs

Our partner Cambridge Credit Counseling offers debt management programs. They negotiate with collectors on your behalf. You make one monthly payment to the counseling agency.

Debt management programs often reduce interest rates. They can also eliminate late fees. Your credit score may improve as you make consistent payments.

Bankruptcy

Bankruptcy eliminates most unsecured debts, including collections. Consider this option if debt overwhelms your finances. Chapter 7 bankruptcy discharges debt in three to six months.

Chapter 13 bankruptcy creates a three to five-year repayment plan. You pay what you can afford based on income. Remaining debt gets discharged after completing the plan.

Bankruptcy seriously impacts your credit score. The record stays on your report for seven to ten years. Consult with a bankruptcy attorney about your options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff?

McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff is a legitimate debt collection agency based in Bedford Heights, Ohio. They've operated for over 41 years with A+ BBB accreditation. MB&W collects debt for credit cards, utilities, medical care, auto loans, and student loans on behalf of original creditors.

How do I verify debt from McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff?

Send a debt validation letter requesting a breakdown of the debt, original creditor details, and your right to dispute. MB&W must provide written verification. Review the notice carefully for errors. Dispute inaccuracies with credit bureaus and check if the statute of limitations has expired before making payments.

Can I settle my debt with McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff for less?

Yes, you can negotiate to settle debt with MB&W for less than the full amount. Evaluate your finances to determine an affordable offer. Submit your settlement offer in writing and negotiate until you reach an agreement. Get the final settlement in writing with signatures before making payment.

What happens if I ignore a lawsuit from McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff?

Ignoring a lawsuit leads to default judgment where MB&W automatically wins. Courts may allow wage garnishment, bank account levies, or property liens. You must file a written Answer within 14-30 days and appear in court on the assigned date to protect your rights.

How can I rebuild credit after dealing with McCarthy, Burgess & Wolff?

Start by settling or paying the collection account. Request a "pay for delete" agreement in writing if possible. Check your credit reports for inaccuracies and dispute errors. Build positive payment history with credit-building tools to offset collection damage and improve your credit score over time.