How to Settle Debt With Caine and Weiner: A Step-by-Step Guide

By Talk About Debt Team
Reviewed by Ben Jackson
Last Updated: February 17, 2026
5 min read
The Bottom Line

You can negotiate with Caine and Weiner to settle your debt for less than the full amount. Always validate the debt first, calculate what you can afford, and get settlement terms in writing. If they sue you, respond immediately with an Answer to avoid a default judgment and preserve your negotiation power.

Answer Your Lawsuit

Receiving a debt collection notice feels scary and intimidating. You’re not alone in this situation. If Caine and Weiner contacted you about a debt, you have options to resolve it.

Caine and Weiner may not be your original lender. They’re a third-party debt collection agency hired to collect delinquent accounts. Once hired, they use various methods to collect what’s owed.

Respond to Caine and Weiner's Lawsuit Today

Don't let Caine and Weiner get a default judgment against you. File your Answer now to protect your wages and property while preserving your ability to negotiate a better settlement.

Respond to Lawsuit

What to Expect in Your First Letter

Your first letter from Caine and Weiner should contain specific information:

  • Your name and contact information
  • The original lender’s name
  • Amount of money owed

The letter will explain how to pay the debt. It will also include instructions on how to dispute it. You have 30 days to dispute the debt by sending a debt validation letter. All collection activity must stop until they substantiate your debt.

Always validate the debt, even if you think it’s yours. Debt collectors handle high volumes of accounts. They often mix up accounts or lose important documentation.

What Is Caine and Weiner?

Caine and Weiner is a third-party debt collection agency. They operate from Sherman Oaks, California. The company purchases overdue consumer and business debts. These include credit cards, loans, and medical debts. Founded in 1930, they’re one of America’s oldest debt collectors.

Contact them using this information:

  • Phone: 1-818-902-4255
  • Address: 5805 Sepulveda Blvd. 4th Floor, Sherman Oaks, CA 91411, USA
  • Mailing Address: PO Box 55848, Sherman Oaks, CA 91413-0848

Who Does Caine and Weiner Collect For?

Caine and Weiner purchase delinquent accounts from various companies. They provide first-party and third-party collection services across major industries. Their clients include many Fortune 500 companies. Some notable clients are Kroger, Wurth Baer Supply Company, and International Workplace Group.

Online Reviews: What Others Say

Real consumer reviews provide valuable insights. You can find Caine and Weiner reviews on several platforms:

  • Better Business Bureau
  • Google Reviews
  • CFPB Consumer Complaint Database
  • Yelp

Reviews for Caine and Weiner vary significantly. Some consumers report positive experiences when communicating directly with representatives. Proactive communication improves your chances of reaching a resolution. Effective dialogue is essential for debt settlement success.

How to Negotiate and Settle Your Debt

You received a summons and complaint from Caine and Weiner. Now is the time to act decisively. Ignoring the lawsuit won’t make it disappear. Taking proactive steps could reduce your settlement amount significantly.

Follow these steps to negotiate your debt settlement:

  1. Respond to the lawsuit with a timely Answer. Avoiding a default judgment is crucial for settlement negotiations.
  2. Calculate what you can afford to pay. Don’t jeopardize essential expenses like rent, utilities, and transportation.
  3. Start settlement discussions with Caine and Weiner. Make your initial offer lower than your calculated amount. You’ll have room to negotiate upward.
  4. Get all settlement terms in writing before agreeing.
  5. Both parties must sign the settlement agreement.
  6. Pay the negotiated amount promptly according to terms.

Want help negotiating without phone calls? Our partner Solo provides digital settlement tools to resolve your debt online.

Your Rights Under the FDCPA

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act protects you from abusive tactics. Debt collectors cannot engage in certain actions when collecting debts.

Caine and Weiner cannot:

  • Call before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m.
  • Threaten you or use profanity
  • Call repeatedly or let the phone ring excessively
  • Contact your workplace when prohibited
  • Pretend to be attorneys or law enforcement

These represent just some prohibited activities under the FDCPA. Many other tactics are expressly forbidden by law. If you believe your rights were violated, file a complaint. You can report violations to the Better Business Bureau or Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

What to Do If Caine and Weiner Sues You

Caine and Weiner filed a lawsuit against you. Immediate action is required. Without a response, the court may issue a default judgment. Default judgments allow wage garnishment and property liens.

File a written Answer responding to their claims. Your Answer should demand specific information from Caine and Weiner:

  • Proof you are the legal debtor
  • Complete substantiation of the debt
  • Authorization to collect this debt

Debt collectors sometimes cannot fully substantiate their claims. When they fail to provide proof, courts dismiss lawsuits. You could win by simply demanding proper documentation.

Consider Suzie’s example. Caine and Weiner sued her for an old credit card debt. She denied all claims in her Answer. Caine and Weiner purchased her charged-off account but never received proper documentation. They couldn’t prove their case. The court dismissed the lawsuit. Suzie won.

How to Draft Your Answer

Drafting and filing an Answer requires three essential steps. Our partner Solo can help you respond to the lawsuit correctly.

  1. Respond to each numbered paragraph in the Complaint. Admit, deny, or claim insufficient knowledge for each argument.
  2. Assert your Affirmative Defenses. These are reasons why Caine and Weiner doesn’t have a case.
  3. File your Answer with the court and plaintiff’s attorneys.

Acting quickly protects your rights and opens settlement opportunities. You have the power to challenge this lawsuit successfully.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Caine and Weiner?

Caine and Weiner is a third-party debt collection agency based in Sherman Oaks, California. Founded in 1930, they purchase and collect overdue consumer and business debts including credit cards, loans, and medical debts for various companies including Fortune 500 clients.

How do I validate a debt from Caine and Weiner?

You have 30 days from receiving their first letter to send a debt validation letter. Once sent, all collection activity must stop until they provide proof you owe the debt, the correct amount, and their authorization to collect. Always validate debts to ensure accuracy.

What happens if I ignore a lawsuit from Caine and Weiner?

Ignoring a lawsuit leads to a default judgment against you. This allows Caine and Weiner to garnish your wages or place liens on your property. You must file a written Answer with the court within the deadline stated in your summons to protect your rights.

Can I negotiate a lower settlement amount with Caine and Weiner?

Yes, you can negotiate to settle for less than the full amount owed. Calculate what you can afford, start with a lower offer, and negotiate upward. Always get settlement terms in writing and signed by both parties before making payment.

What are my rights when Caine and Weiner contacts me?

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act protects you from abusive tactics. Caine and Weiner cannot call before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m., use threats or profanity, call repeatedly, contact your workplace when prohibited, or misrepresent themselves as attorneys or law enforcement.